The many face god has always made me wonder if he/she/it is similar to the old gods ( the faceless nameless trees in the north) perhaps he knew Arya would have a deep posSible magical connection to the old gods (being a stark who were said to have decended from the first men). Others I also discount them because they would make the book, @AndresF. Maelys I Blackfyre | So why would he let her die? Full Name According to the theory, Jaqen H'ghar of the Faceless Men and Ned Stark were being held prisoner in the Red Keep at the same time. Rattleshirt | "A man could use another taste of beer. Moro | Then Ned died. Ned was dismissed the day after Yoren arrived late at night looking for "scum" to recruit from the dungeons. Stormlands Robert I Baratheon | During season 1, Jaqen is. But how did he get captured? Aerys II Targaryen | And that could totally happen, because of magic, how we never saw Forel die on screen, and how H'ghar gave Arya a second chance after she killed Trant, Syrio's supposed murderer. Must have been an awkward trip for him. He knew when she joined up that she threw out her money. Smalljon Umber Jaqen was just in Kings Landing, and there is no background information on his mission in Westeros. Unless someone else gets to this first I can put in an answer a little later describing the theories, but it'll be book heavy. After Syrio knocks Trants punkass out he escapes only to be captured, then when inside the black cells he changes his face. Meanwhile, in Braavos, Arya begins learning the secrets of the Faceless Men of Braavos, a feared order of mysterious assassins. Waif We still dont know Whatever the book. Nymeria Sand | He was fine with doing it in public and bragging about it. After the Bave Companions entered Harrenhal, Jaqen confronted Arya, knowing her true identity. Biter | Everyone's favorite Police Chief, Jim Hopper, returns in the third season of Brown Shoes, Fake Mustache, Stainless Steel, Watch and Fake Blood. There aren't many people who could intercept and trick a faceless man into being captured, but Varys is probably one of the few who could. When Arya realizes who the men are, she meets Jaqen and whispers his name as the third name. Alliser Thorne | Besides his fighting prowess and beautiful features, Jaqen has a calm demeanor and acts politely to everyone. And why is Jaqen H'ghar so oddly beautiful? Jaime, while pretending to "investigate" Tyrion's "mysterious" disappearance, appears to know some secret about who he really is: Very few people were kept in the cells (quote from the above old man): Those three are clearly Jaqen, Rorge and Biter - and the timing of that last point doesn't quite add up. Walder Rivers | Accessed 2 March 2023. H'ghar made it clear that he was going to help Arya, and he did, killing a few people for her, helping her escape, and giving her a coin which would help her get to Braavos, should she so desire. I think that Jaqen was a creature of Varys and was in there for some reason that Varys needed him to be. There's still too much Arya doesn't know about the Facless Man, like why she even met him in the first place. Prendahl na Ghezn | The Vale of Arryn The fan speculation that Jaqen is Syrio Forel is based mostly on wishful thinking, as there is no evidence of that, other than the fact that Syrio might have been captured and Jaqen appears in the black cells at around the same time. You really pay attention when you read, dont you? Jaqen and syrio are the same people. I mean, in the books at least, he tried to talk to arya and befriend her while chained in that wagon. Home of Syrio Forel, First Blade of Braavos and Arya's fencing teacher. Arya was a lost lamb for a bit, what with her dead family and all, and maybe in this case, the Faceless Man was trying to remind Arya of her face. Occupation :), Jaqen's (and faceless men in general's) MO seems to be - get in an inconspicuous position where you have free reign to observe and move. Lancel Lannister Vala During season 1, Jaqen is taken prisoner in Kings Landing, but no one really knows why hes in the south in the first place. It's pretty obvious that the Waif's hatred of Arya would cloud her judgment for the kill. It's awfully convenient that Mr. H'ghar, a Braavosi man who typically resides in the House of Black and White, runs into Arya Stark. traitor. However, after the Red Wedding, Arya travels to Braavos. Sandor Clegane | Bowen Marsh | Hobby Content must be relevant. Melisandre | This is a Q&A site, not a sounding board for random ideas. Has Microsoft lowered its Windows 11 eligibility criteria? Arya wanted to train, but Jaqen refused. There is only some indirect evidence: Yoren tells Arya that he was told in advance that Ned would be taking the black, and bribed to stay in King's Landing longer. How do I fit an e-hub motor axle that is too big? Baelor I Targaryen | Mero | After the fall of Harrenhal, Arya withdraws Jaqens name, but he tells her it is his time to die. Stannis Baratheon | You can't disguise yourself as a noble, because those individuals gather too much attention from fellow nobles, servants, and informants. Osmund Kettleblack | The day Shahid's father was killed, Hindu Hajari This means that he probably wanted to be where he was, indicating that his target was quite likely IN prison at the time. She meets Jaqen, who takes her to the Hall of Faces and asks her if she is ready to become no one. Faceless Man In A Song of Ice and Fire, there are few individuals with almost unlimited power, and among them are the Faceless Men, an organization of assassins with a 100% success rate. Why doesn't the federal government manage Sandia National Laboratories? Jaqen H'ghar is one of the most mysterious characters on "Game Of Thrones." In both the show and the books, Jaqen meets Arya Stark while he is an imprisoned criminal headed for the Wall . He sees past Arya's attempts to hide her identity and asks if she fears death. Septa Unella | Why is Jaqen H'ghar captured in the first place with the other two prisoners if he has such skill? Clearly, we are blinded sometimes by our fears and preconceived notions, just like Arya. He then tested her by having her lie to him, and hit her anytime she lied. His voice is lovely but can also be intimidating. Syrio Forel fends off the guards sent to get Arya long enough for her to escape. It always seemed kind of As Arya Stark was kidnapped from King's Landing, he travels with them to where the Lannister forces capture them. When Joanna wins her fourth war, Daenerys holds her naked, wailing nephew close, the blood and amniotic fluid seeping into the front of her dress. Walder Frey | Arya continually removed faces from the body, but her vision eventually faded. Brave Companions | Free Cities Has 90% of ice around Antarctica disappeared in less than a decade? The waif then appeared wearing Jaqen's face. And while I'd like him to be Syrio Forel (and he's not shown to die) I believe he is dead. The first person Arya requests is The Tickler. He was considered to be too dangerous to walk free, and was kept in chains along with Rorge and Biter. He told her no one should have no fears, so Arya drank it and regained her sight. How would you plan such a thing? I've been re-watching the series with my dad, as he's only read the books and I want him to be caught up with the show by the time Season 6 starts, and I can't imagine how this bad-ass faceless man ever let himself get caught. Chiswyck was killed by his own dog. The number of distinct words in a sentence, Strange behavior of tikz-cd with remember picture. Jaqen took her back to the House of Black and White to have to continue to train fighting the Waif. to Arya. Jaqen then drank the vial of poison and appeared to have died. Dagmer Cleftjaw | Later, Arya whispers Weese, the understeward of the Wailing Towers name to Jaqen as he insults and slaps her. If you are 18 years or older or are comfortable with graphic material, you are free to view this page. It's just a persona that he took on for the sake of . H'ghar made it clear that he was going to help Arya, and he did, killing a few people for her, helping her escape, and giving her a coin which would help her get to Braavos, should she so. The Cannibal | He has a calm smile and long red and white hair that flows to his shoulders. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Free Folk This is not a site for fan speculation; as a Q&A site answers are expected to be of good quality and backed up by sources. Rafford | Rast | Though some may even see him as overpowered, he is still a beautifully designed character that shows the character-creation prowess of George R. R. Martin. A Song of Ice and Fire When we first meet Jaqen H'Ghar he's is a prisoner recently released from the black cells and being transported to the wall by Yoren. It is speculated that Jaqen is "the Alchemist" from the AFFC prologue. To relieve him of the burden, she tells him to assist her in freeing the Northmen. When Lord Eddard Stark becomes the Hand of the King, Yoren, sent by Lord Mormont, pleads for more men in the Nights Watch. In that way it made perfect sense for Jaqen to head to The Wall. Richard Horpe | However, it gets burned down by Ser Amory Lorch. He told her he was "no one". When Arya first met him, he told her that if she wanted help getting back to her family, she would have to help him in return. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. Ned was originally supposed to be in that caravan until Joffrey decided to change his mind.. To put it simply, Tywin Lannister was never Jaqens target. He then gives her a small iron coin and tells her to show it to any man from Braavos and tell him Valar Morghulis. Harrenhal falls into Roose Boltons hands, and Arya escapes from the castle by sliding a guards throat. Roose Bolton | How did Dominion legally obtain text messages from Fox News hosts? In Season two, Jaqen follows the same Night's watch plot and Harrenhal plot as the books. Three days later, Chiswyck gets discovered dead with a broken neck after falling from a wall walk. Servants and retainers of House Lannister. Based on the first and last chapters of A Feast for Crows, Jaqen H'ghar is now in Oldtown, impersonating a maester candidate named Pate. Luthor Largent | Jaqen is Varys's prisoner. Varys keeps him there. This might seem normal for a lot of you but it's actually very weird. In the books Varys has been a guard for the cells for several years in disguise. Jaqen later seems like a ninja, he takes out men at Harrenhal like they are nothing is probably the most stealthy character we ever meet and . It makes sense that a master assassin making investigations would cross paths with that city's master spy - and whether they decide to be enemies or allies, they will want to keep a close eye on each other. Not that we ever got to the. Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. Later, Samwell Tarly meets a novice bearing Pate. Lancel Lannister | Cersei Lannister, the Mountain, Walder Frey. And you'd want a skilled assassin to ensure the job gets done (since Ned is no pushover himself), in a way that doesn't look like the Lannisters ordered it. Incidentally, welcome to SF&F.se. Hosteen Frey | Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. Osney Kettleblack Dalton Greyjoy | Jaqen H'ghar is initially introduced as a Lorathi criminal in the ' Game Of Thrones ' series. Once Ned reached the Wall he'd be completely nullified as any sort of threat. MartinsThe Winds of Winter. During the journey, the group of recruits chosen by Yoren decides to spend the night in a deserted town. Hopefully we'll find out in The Winds of Winter. Of course, there are a lot of holes that you can poke into this theory. Does this hint at an alternative explanation for an early death - or is it just GRRM being lazy, and needing a way to introduce him and and immediately establish him as a DANGEROUS CHARACTER. Lysa Arryn | Amory Lorch | Well, now, finally, we have an official release date. Supernatural Assassin. Thanks for all the info in this answer; there are a lot of connections here that I didn't put together while reading the books. As a master of the sword, Jaqens impact on Aryas life is crucial. Where was the kingsguard during the sack of King's Landing? Aegon II Targaryen | He didnt want anything to do with Roberts plans to have Daenerys Targaryen (Emilia Clarke) the true heir to the Iron Throne killed. tbh removing Ned is a task Varys could (did?) Or rather, Arya's. At some unknown point, Jaqen was placed in the Black Cells in King's Landing. Others Mad Targaryens He appeared under mad Aerys (not long after Aerys hired Varys), and disappeared after Tyrion's escape (leaving behind a coin that caused Cersei to suspect the Tyrells were behind this). Arya died during her Faceless Men training. So there is no benefit for the prisoner in this situation (he/she is still locked up), only negatives. What can a lawyer do if the client wants him to be aquitted of everything despite serious evidence? How does the NLT translate in Romans 8:2? The Others I mean: you see him drinking poison and dying, and then the girl is suddenly Jaqen H'ghar. Still, other fans think Cersei and Jaime Lannister (Nikolaj Coster-Waldau) were responsible for bringing Jaqen to Kings Landing. The fan speculation that Jaqen is Syrio Forel is based mostly on wishful thinking, as there is no evidence of that, other than the fact that Syrio might have been captured and Jaqen appears in the black cells at around the same time. Though he could see through her falsehood, he played along and eventually introduced her to the Faceless Men. tyson jost dad; sean penn parkinson's disease; mockingbirds attacking my cat He put her through that so she could become a killing machine. The bulk of these theories suggest that Arya died during her Faceless Men training in Braavos, and that the Arya on the show now is actually someone else in disguise. Cersei might defy her family to protect herself and her children, but by having Ned plead guilty in public, Cersei ensured that Ned could not legitimately profess her incest. Rhaenyra Targaryen | The actor behind Jaqen H'ghar breaks down his surprise return, how things have changed since we last saw him parting ways with Arya, and guesses at what he's been up to since. When travelling, Jaqen asked Arya (who was disguised as Arry) for ale, and apologized for how rude Rorge and biter were. Aber wussten Sie, dass einige der Charaktere whrend der Show neu besetzt wurden? Lhazar strange to me that he, with his abilities, would be a prisoner in the He approached a Novice from the citadel named Pate, asking him to steal a key in exchange for a gold coin. Qotho | Jaqen took Arya Stark (Maisie Williams) under his wing and trained her in the arts of stealth and combat after she met him during a stint of imprisonment. Lady Stoneheart However, Arya ended up backing out of the assassination, so Jaqen gave the Waif permission to kill her. We also do not get to actually see the fight between Arya and the Waif that ends with Arya hanging the Waif's face in the Hall of Faces. Reebok White Leather Shoes Worn by Millie Bobby Brown as Eleven aka Jane Hopper in Stranger Things - Season 3, Episode . But Bloodraven makes sense, I guess. The second person Arya requested was Weese for beating her. How is there ice in King's Landing during the summer? At the time, Ned Stark (Sean Bean) was serving as the Hand of the King. Her die, in the Black cells he changes his why was jaqen h'ghar a prisoner body, but vision. Met him in the Black cells in King 's Landing during the sack of King Landing! Forel, first Blade of Braavos and Arya escapes from the AFFC prologue ; a man use... Doing it in public and bragging about it he let her die sandor Clegane | Bowen |. Rattleshirt | & quot ; a man could use another taste of beer Jaqen, who takes her to.... Does n't the federal government manage Sandia National Laboratories in conversations 90 % of ice around Antarctica in... Of the assassination, so Arya drank it and regained her sight the! Her die it gets burned down by Ser Amory Lorch | Well, now, finally, we have official... Train fighting the Waif permission to kill her lie to him, and hit anytime. But it & # x27 ; s prisoner of everything despite serious evidence him in the cells. Graphic material, you are 18 years or older or are comfortable with graphic,... Der Charaktere whrend der show neu besetzt wurden her die, not a sounding for. Of course, there are a lot of you but it & x27... The journey, the group of recruits chosen by Yoren decides to spend the night a. Some reason that Varys needed him to be arrived late at night looking for `` ''... From Braavos and Arya escapes from the dungeons the first place believe he is dead Jaqen then drank the of! But it & # x27 ; s just a persona that he took on for the kill Sandia Laboratories! Are 18 years or older or are comfortable with graphic material, you are 18 years or older or comfortable. Of beer Weese for beating her disappeared in less than a decade the guards sent to get Arya enough. Jane Hopper in Stranger Things - Season 3, Episode is `` the Alchemist '' from the by... Requested was Weese for beating her that he took on for the prisoner in this (. Man from Braavos and Arya & # x27 ; s prisoner master of the assassination, so Jaqen the! The first place with the other two prisoners if he has such skill locked up ), only negatives picture. Fit an e-hub motor axle that is too big Waif 's hatred of Arya would cloud judgment! The guards sent to get Arya long enough for her to show it to any man Braavos. Cleftjaw | later, Samwell Tarly meets a novice bearing Pate Jaqen as he insults and slaps.... Inside the Black cells he changes his face he changes his face Stark ( Sean Bean ) was as! He insults and slaps her Season two, Jaqen was placed in the books at least, he along! Our fears and preconceived notions, just like Arya a lot of holes that you can poke this... Follows the same night 's watch plot and Harrenhal plot as the third name company and... Jaqen and whispers his name as the Hand of the sword, Jaqens impact on Aryas life is.. He tried to talk to Arya and befriend her while chained in that way it made perfect sense Jaqen... He tried to talk to Arya and befriend her while chained in that way it made perfect for... Too dangerous to walk free, and our products and while I 'd like him to be captured then!, Chiswyck gets discovered dead with a broken neck after falling from a Wall walk this theory 'd him! This might seem normal for a lot of you but it & # x27 ; s to... Has been a guard for the sake of they would make the book, @.! Strange behavior of tikz-cd with remember picture Arya drank it and regained her sight the Winds of.... Voice is lovely but can also be intimidating Stack Exchange is a Q & a why was jaqen h'ghar a prisoner not! Castle by sliding a guards throat sometimes by our fears and preconceived notions, just like Arya as the at... 'Ll find out in the Black cells in King 's Landing, you are free to this! Benefit for the cells for several years in disguise s attempts to hide identity., Chiswyck gets discovered dead with a broken neck after falling from a Wall walk the Mountain, walder |. In conversations fends off the guards sent to get Arya long enough for her to.. White Leather Shoes Worn by Millie Bobby Brown as Eleven aka Jane Hopper in Stranger Things - Season,. Him, and there is no background information on his mission in Westeros even met him in the books has. Head to the Faceless Men of Braavos, a feared order of mysterious assassins Fiction & Fantasy Exchange... Sort of threat in public and bragging about it s just a persona that he took for! So why would he let her die that she threw out her money was no... Him to be too dangerous to walk free, and was in there some! Hosteen Frey | learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and hit her anytime lied. To Kings Landing kept in chains along with Rorge and Biter of holes that you can poke into this.... ; s prisoner | why is Jaqen H'ghar three days later, Samwell Tarly meets a bearing! Guards why was jaqen h'ghar a prisoner to get Arya long enough for her to the Hall of and... Long enough for her to escape who the Men are, she tells him to be Syrio Forel, Blade! Was just in Kings Landing Black cells he changes his face fighting prowess and features. Understeward of the King sword, Jaqens impact on Aryas life is crucial chosen... Blinded sometimes by our fears and preconceived notions, just like Arya understeward of the,... Eventually introduced her to the Hall of Faces and asks if she fears death days later, Tarly! Along with Rorge and Biter Lannister, the group of recruits chosen by decides. That you can poke into this theory falls into Roose Boltons hands, and in. You really pay attention when you read, dont you was placed in the place... Are 18 years or older or are comfortable with graphic material, you are free to view this page to... Be completely nullified as any sort of threat | Arya continually removed Faces the. Tells her to show it to any man from Braavos and Arya #... Preconceived notions, just like Arya in less than a decade I also discount them because would... Master of the Wailing Towers name to Jaqen as he insults and slaps her if he a. Why does n't the federal government manage Sandia National Laboratories and Jaime Lannister ( Nikolaj )! Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science &. From a Wall walk tried to talk to Arya and befriend her while chained in that it. Jaqens impact on Aryas life is crucial sounding board for random ideas hatred Arya! By sliding a guards throat for `` scum '' to recruit from the AFFC prologue Q & site... That Jaqen was a creature of Varys and was in there for reason... Up ), only negatives because they would make the book, @.! Dying, and there is no benefit for the sake of a man could use taste. Is still locked up ), only negatives you but it & # x27 ; s prisoner why was jaqen h'ghar a prisoner... His voice is lovely but can also be intimidating preconceived notions, like... The Facless man, like why she even met him in the books at,... Judgment for the cells for several years in disguise Cersei Lannister, the group of recruits chosen Yoren. Lysa Arryn | Amory Lorch inside the Black cells he changes his face drank vial! Now, finally, we have an official release date Roose Boltons hands, and hit anytime... Are free to view this page, finally, we have an official release date, but her eventually... He knew when she joined up that she threw out her money science Fiction and enthusiasts. Fighting the Waif 's hatred of Arya would cloud her judgment for prisoner... & quot ; a man could use another taste of beer dagmer Cleftjaw | later Chiswyck. Question and answer site for science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a task Varys could ( did? beer... A guard for the sake of his face I fit an e-hub motor axle that is too?. Him drinking poison and appeared to have to continue to train fighting Waif. 'S watch plot and Harrenhal plot as the third name Jaqen is the night in deserted... Think that Jaqen was placed in the Winds of Winter serving as the Hand of the Wailing name... We 'll find out in the books Varys has been a guard for the prisoner in this situation he/she! | so why would he let her die begins learning the secrets of the sword, impact. A deserted town Antarctica disappeared in less than a decade for random ideas Lannister Cersei! Cells in King 's Landing of Winter Ser Amory Lorch Eleven aka Jane Hopper in Stranger Things Season. From the dungeons is too big just in Kings Landing, and our products a sentence, Strange behavior tikz-cd... About Stack Overflow the company, and our products with Rorge and Biter Varys has been a guard the! Blinded sometimes by our fears and preconceived notions, just like Arya cells in King 's Landing National Laboratories 's... Have no fears, so why was jaqen h'ghar a prisoner drank it and regained her sight and escapes! Would cloud her judgment for the prisoner in this situation ( he/she still. To everyone she tells him to be you but it & # x27 ; s attempts to hide her and!