Both brands have established a good reputation in the industry. But, which one should you get? If you compare it to the first models of cargo boxes that have been released a couple of years ago, the drastic change of opening mechanisms is noticeable. So, its just a perfect balance. The Yakima Carbonite 16 Cargo Box is not an exception. Just wondering if people have experience with either product and would recommend one over the other if cost isn't a huge issue. This cargo carrier has a solid handle and is dual-opening, making it very easy to load or unload with gear. The GrandTour has the standard Yakima locking core that, as we mentioned above, can be replaced if you want to rekey your cargo carrier to match your crossbars or if you lose the keys. The Yakima Skybox Carbonite 16, Goplus Rooftop Carrier, and the Thule Force XT XL are next regarding ease of use. Which one makes the better car racks? Hence, we encourage you not to store bulky gears and items inside your cargo box. It also looks a bit stubbier and less sleek and stylish overall than some of its pricier counterparts. As mentioned earlier, the huge capacity of this cargo box allows you to put anything you want. At $830 for the 18-cubic-foot version, the GrandTour features a high-gloss finish, sophisticated wide profile, and contoured base that keeps it sitting low on the crossbars. It holds a ton of stuff, is long enough for skis or other long gear, and has a good closing/locking mechanism. And if you are torn continuously in choosing Thule vs. Yakima cargo boxes, there are a few factors that you need to consider. Thule is a Swedish company thats been around since 1942. Over torque the nut, bending the L-bracket (loosens the mount), forcing the foot into the glass. But if you dont mind spending an extra few dollars on increasing the storage of your vehicle, then this is the right cargo box for you. This cargo carrier is one of the easiest models to both install and use we particularly like the relatively smooth interior that keeps your gear from getting caught on anything while loading or unloading. 4. Thule Force has no handle, but only a key to turn. msc777; Aug 17, 2021 . We are debating between the Thule Motion XT (XL?) The Yakima HoldUp Evo is pretty similar to The Thule T2 regarding the size and bike capacity. Yakima has an edge in roof bike racks because they're the company's main focus. All trademarks property of their respective owners Adding only about 10 in. It has a dual-opening lid so you can access your gear from both sides of the car, and the quick clamps make installation and removal a breeze. The single-piece clamp of the Yakima GrandTour can fit a variety of different crossbars. Also, Thule cargo boxes feature pull chords. The 18 cubic foot model can hold items up to 210 cm more than enough for the majority of alpine skis on the market. Although we tend to prioritize function over form for most categories, we do recognize that cargo boxes can be an eyesore and are something you'll have to see daily while on your vehicle. All user preferences and both are excellent boxes. It is suitable for customers on a tight budget, although there are several Thule cargo boxes that are sold at a reasonable price, as well. While it isn't the cheapest roof box, it offers a surprisingly good price per cubic foot and a top-tier performance overall. Also, Yakima manufactures cargo boxes with outdoor enthusiasts in mind. We have tested plenty of cargo boxes that are annoying to operate, but this one flat-out works nicely and comes in at a reasonable price. Anyone who owned a Yakima product before knows that this company is known for combining functionality and style into one perfect cargo box. This will serve as your guide when in the market, looking for the best cargo box. One of them is the adjustable spacing between the bikes. Most manufacturers help you narrow your choices according to your cars make, model, and year. Whether you're packing up all your camping gear before heading out on a backpacking or climbing trip, or traveling to a new beautiful location to ski or snowboard, a cargo box can help you stay organized and maximize space inside your vehicle. Attached are some photos of the 11 cu ft Thule Force XT Sport cargo roof box on OEM roof racks. It is user-friendly. But the wide range of products can make choosing one difficult. Read more: SportRack Horizon Alpine review. It opens on both sides, is quite durable and secure, and looks good on most cars. While there may be colleagues who will recommend what he uses, it may not always work with how you want it to work for you. It is made to resist the harsh elements of nature, but when it gets too windy, or the snow is too thick, the items inside the cargo box can be affected. Weve researched materials, structure, and price points to help you decide. We evaluated how user-friendly each one was for day-to-day use and noted any significant changes in vehicle handling and fuel efficiency. When it comes to the lid, Yakima had done an excellent job of keeping it sturdy. Opening the SkyBox's sturdy lid with ease. That means you can open the box from either side, making it more convenient to you in case you are in a hurry and forgot something in the cargo box. Product Specs Weight: 62.50 lbs. Our first set of tests and evaluations for these roof-mounted cargo boxes focuses on how easy they are to install or remove from a typical vehicle and how convenient it is to store and load your gear. Some models from Yakima and Thule features a strap attached inside the lid. I am looking at these low profile boxes specifically for garage clearance issues and aerodynamics to keep on most of the time. In this case, the Canyon XT would be worth the extra $150 or so for something attractive atop your vehicle. The Goplus is a great option if you want to save some cash and don't need to carry extra-long items. The Yakima RocketBox Pro 14 is a great bargain buy, perfect for anyone wanting an all-around excellent cargo carrier without paying the high price of a top-tier model. While there are a few cases where one company has a clear advantage (such as the Thule Hullavator for lift-assisted kayak loading) for the most part there is no difference in quality between the accessories of each brand. To determine if it'll fit on your CX-5, you'll need to measure from the center of the front crossbar rearward until you . HighRoad costs $249, while HighSpeed runs $239. The Vector has a mounting system similar to the Motion and has all the features you could want, including an integrated light and an interior pad. The click will indicate that you had successfully installed the cargo box in its correct tension. I am using OEM crossbars. This factor is only applicable if you are planning to buy a roof cargo box. Two excellent products are HighRoad and HighSpeed. Yakima GrandTour Rooftop Cargo Box - 16 Cubic Ft - Gloss Black (20) $878.95. The GrandTour feels like one of the more solid options of the group. It does not only look elegant, but it is outstanding in hiding scrapes and scratches. Once the clamps are loosened sufficiently to clear your crossbars, you can lift them up and onto your rack with the help of a friend and then use the same tool to tighten them. The low profile of this Thule Hyper XL cargo box makes it very stylish for storage space. The RocketBox Pro 14 is very quick and easy to install in our experience. Were we able to notice the difference, especially comparative differences between each box? The clamps also have a wider range than most, allowing this box to secure to more sizes and shapes of crossbars. The textured finish on the SportRack Vista seemed a little cheap to us, to the point where we felt it might detract from the appearance of nicer cars. However, we found after testing that there wasn't a significant impact on how a variety of different test cars handled, regardless if we were traveling on the freeway at high speeds, over windy mountain passes, or over potholes and bumps on rough roads. Just real, honest, side-by-side testing. . The classy Yakima GrandTour has an almost mirror-like finish. This system consists of crossbars that bridge the width of your roof. However, it does look slick when it's clean. This roof box is one of the most expensive options we have tested and is likely outside the budget for many people. It is designed in a way that will keep your gears safe and easy to access. Appearance While it isn't a big factor to consider in getting a cargo box, appearance is still part of its over-all features. This helped us develop a picture of how much or little effort was required when using these boxes on a daily basis. Roof box: Thule Motion XT vs Yakima GrandTour? piloteers.org is an independent Honda enthusiast website owned and operated by VerticalScope Inc. Other models still use traditional handles. You just need to locate the keys taped to the exterior of the box, open the lid, then use the included torque wrench to loosen each clamp. You can even extend the cargo space by adding an accessory. To ensure objectivity, we purchase all the products we test and never accept any free products or incentives from manufacturers. They did come in a surprising amount of finishes, though, and we had clear preferences. While a determined thief could access the contents of these boxes with enough force or specialized tools, there are differences between how much effort would be required to open each box and how secure they feel. Overall, we think this is a solid cargo carrier. All trademarks property of their respective owners Thule Motion XT Lroof box black glossy. Komplettfrpackade lasthllare / takrcke till Renault Clio. What do you like about your box versus the Thule Motion XT or Yakima GrandTour? We also like that these clamps have a wider range of crossbar compatibility than some of the other models, wrapping around the third-party square crossbars we used for testing much more completely than some of the other models we have tested. We buy all the products ourselves. Got feedback? While it didn't sustain any noticeable wear and tear during testing, we are mildly concerned that the extremely glossy finish will show scratches and scuffs much more readily than some of the textured matte cargo boxes. Yakima specializes in affordability and durability. On top of that, the key also can't be removed if the box is unlocked, making it much more difficult to accidentally drive off with the cargo carrier unlocked. And, you are confident it will last the same amount of time as Thule Force. It's a great option if you don't want to spend a ton of cash on a cargo solution for your car, but this box is far from flawless. This means that there are multiple holes on the bottom, consequently leaving multiple points for water to get in. The mounting system is very easy; just turn some dials. For $549, Skybox is nearly on par of the expensive ones. Loading, unloading, and security features should also be considered. Thule also has a couple of good crossbars in the Evo Wingbar and AeroBlade Edge. Distinctive automotive badging Hauls gear for up to 3 campers; fits snowboards and skis up to 185cm Made in the USA Yakima cannot ship the GrandTour 16 to Alaska or Hawaii - please contact a local dealer. We spent more time trying to locate where the manufacturer had taped the key than actually mounting it the first time. Wind fairing helps reduce the cargo baskets road noise and improves fuel efficiency. Yakima Yakima GrandTour 16 Roof Box 4.9 15 Reviews Item #171034 Top Rated Black $879.00 Color: Black Quantity Ship to address $160 oversize shipping Shipping restrictions apply Pick up in store or curbsideFREE Find this item in store Members get an estimated $87.90 back on this item. $899.95 Rating: Color: Black Black Black . Both Force and Skybox required no assembly. This is what the Thule Force is missing. Below is a comprehensive buying guide that will enlighten the difference between Thule and Yakima cargo boxes. The Horizon Alpine is a bare-bones product that can't compare to the top-tier products in terms of convenience features but retails at a fraction of the cost of the top models. You shouldnt decide just by looking at it. Thule, being known as a trusted manufacturer of cargo boxes in the market, also offers excellent customer services. After all, you wouldnt want an eyesore on top of your car. On your next travel adventure, you no longer have to worry about fitting all your gears and items in your car. As a father of a four-year-old and six-year-old, he enjoys passing down his passions by teaching his children all about his interests. None of these boxes showed any significant signs of damage through normal wear and tear, though most showed a handful of scrapes and scuffs from repeatedly installing and uninstalling them. We like how easy to use and how sleek and stylish it is, but it's certainly more of a financial commitment for most people unless you are planning on using a cargo box all the time, not just for the occasional road trip. GearLab is reader-supported. I have a Thule Motion XT and it's great. You can place all your gears inside without difficulty. Thule and Yakima have two of the best of their products to help you. To date, theyve taken seven family trips to various trails throughout Oregon, Washington state, and Montana (where they have family), and he aims to continue his growing familys health and wellness through these activities. Yakima's large cargo boxes can store up to 6 pairs of skis that are up to 215cm in length. Yakima GrandTour 18 Cubic Ft Premium Rooftop Cargo Box Manufacturer Demo review and installation instructions. Comparatively, Thule offers TopRide and FastRide. The clamps push through a slit in a piece of rubber sheeting, and we think this provides a better seal than the vinyl stickers but not as good as the top-tier models with quick clamps that have a sliding seal. A cargo box is designed to protect your gears while in transit. Thule Motion XT Rooftop Cargo Box - 16 cu ft - Black Glossy (485 reviews) Code: TH629706 Retail: $1,532.00 Our Price: $899.95 Roof Box Aero Bars Elliptical Bars Factory Bars Round Bars Square Bars Medium Length High Profile Large Capacity Dual Side Access Black Thule more information > Product Page this Question was Asked From Home Thule Force vs Yakima Skybox The Ultimate Comparison. I like the Yakima CBX in regards to overall aesthetics and slightly slimmer profile. The Yakima RocketBox Pro 14 and the Goplus Rooftop Carrier are our favorite inexpensive cargo boxes for those on a budget. Introducing the GrandTour Premium Cargo . Thule originated in Swedish, and due to their consistency in delivering the premium-quality cargo boxes in the market, they are known globally. But today, it had been made easier and more convenient, thanks to the innovative opening mechanisms and advanced hinges that have been used. Still, they are all easy to latch and unlatch and won't permit the key to be removed while the box is unlocked, preventing you from forgetting to close it or locking your keys in the box. Priced decently, it is a good investment that is handy for your upcoming trips. Just go for the whatever size you need and if you want something super low profile or not. Write a review. Both Thule and Yakima did an excellent job in the opening and closing mechanisms of their cargo boxes. Even without prior mechanic knowledge, rest assured that youll be able to fix it. Black is probably the universal color for roof boxes. We independently buy, test, and rate all the products we review. Products in this gear category are expensive. For this review, we looked at the 10 best models and tested them head-to-head to find out which rooftop cargo-carrying solution came out on top. We began testing by unpacking and assembling each model while paying close attention to how easy each one is to install and load with gear. That way, you dont have to climb all over the place just to close it. $899.95. They both make excellent boxes, but which one is best made? The Motion XT is certainly an elegant rooftop cargo box, but Yakima's GrandTour gives it a run for its money at a slightly cheaper price point. We've been testing and reviewing cargo boxes for years now and constantly seek new and notable models to add to our review. Aerodynamics is a big concern in hauling anything on your roof. This is where your box will settle. Finally, the size. Put a load on the bars adds more flex to push into the glass. vs Yakima GrandTour (16 vs 18?). The good news is that for almost anything you want to carry both Yakima and Thule offer top-of-the-line accessories for it. Copyright 2006-2022 Tesla Motors Club LLC. As mentioned earlier, Yakima is living by producing a rugged-looking and no-nonsense cargo box. When it comes to opening or closing the box, we are going with Skyboxs Superlatch handle. However, take note that the angle when you can open a cargo box is limited. With these trusted brands, you can enjoy your outdoor experience without any worries. The 16 cubic foot model we tested can fit items up to 185 cm in length (fitting the most common ski lengths). The lid only opens on one side with no way to reconfigure it and it lacks any integrated straps for securing your gear inside. JavaScript is disabled. M. Road Trip Experience + Roof Cargo Box Efficiency. The roof is curved quite a bit. In this Thule vs. Yakima cargo box review, we examined the features, highlights, and even the downgrades of each listed cargo box. Sometimes, space for passengers is sacrificed to accommodate all gears. It came with almost the same hardware as that of Thule Force, however, it wasnt easy to find out which thumbwheel goes to which part. This knowledge will help you to save money and also helps you in selecting the right cargo box for you. roof box black glossy. Got feedback? If you are searching for the best all-around cargo box, we think the Yakima GrandTour 16 is your ticket to ride. It only requires a single person and a few minutes to install. yakima grandtour 16 vs thule motion xteuropean skincare brands yakima grandtour 16 vs thule motion xt. Customers love its sleek and stylish design that will make the car look more luxurious. Consider becoming a Supporting Member of Tesla Motors Club. The PowerClick mounting system on the Force is one of the easiest to use that we have seen to date. Megane Grandtour (03-09) Renault (Grand) Scnic . Thule Motion XT Rooftop Cargo Box - 16 cu ft - Black Glossy. We developed a comprehensive testing plan, evaluating and judging the performance of each product on everything from its ease of installation to how well its finish hides scrapes and scratches. All in all, we think this is a fantastic option for anyone who doesn't want a lot of hassle when it comes to their roof box. Thule is dedicated to providing exceptional products that are quality tested and guaranteed against defects in materials and workmanship. And it comes with a lifetime warranty. Yakima also has a holder for the tool inside the cargo box, so it can live safely and conveniently inside. 8007395 Yakima GrandTour Premium Rooftop Cargo Box - 18 Cubic Ft - Gloss Black Installation Details . This gives a definite boost for versatility and personalization. 9-18, Fre 9-16; Snabba leveranser 1-3 dagar ; Fri frakt p tusentals artiklar Which would you guys choose, the Thule Motion XT L or the Yakima CBX 16? The 16 cubic foot model we tested can fit items up to 185 cm in length (fitting the most common ski lengths). A sturdy handle opens the lid, with clear visual indicators showing if the box is unlocked or locked. We found the Motion XT to be one of the more secure offerings in our lineup. Cracked roof using roof rack w/ cargo box, For Sale: Tesla OEM Roof Racks and Thule Motion XT L Gloss Black roof box, Is Yakima FullSwing bike rack wobble normal. We also looked at the construction and design of the clamps and locking systems, as well as the amount of potential water intrusion. Thule, with all its fame and reputation in the hauling industry, is certainly one of the most expensive brands. Sure. The Yakima GrandTour also opens on both sides and is very easy to install and remove. With its durable construction, sleek design, and huge capacity, this cargo box is ideal for your upcoming long trips. The hybrid mounting system on the Alpine can be a bit finicky until you get the hang of it. Generous load capacity. Square edges and a square wind fairing make it look like a steel box without a lid. It isn't too much of a hassle to take on and off a car once you get the hang of it, and it can hold skis/snowboards up to 210 cm in length a rarity for budget cargo carriers. Or other long gear, and the Goplus is a big concern in hauling anything on your roof Black. You decide specifically for garage clearance issues and aerodynamics to keep on most cars box versus the Thule regarding! Some models from Yakima and Thule features a strap attached inside the cargo box in its correct.... Improves fuel efficiency skis on the Force is one of them is the adjustable spacing between the T2! Applicable if you want to carry both Yakima and Thule offer top-of-the-line accessories for it just close... Was required when using these boxes on a daily yakima grandtour vs thule motion xt ton of stuff, is enough... Or incentives from manufacturers Thule vs. Yakima cargo boxes selecting the right cargo box efficiency than... To the lid, with all its fame and reputation in the market, also offers excellent customer services test! Can enjoy your outdoor experience without any worries box, we think this is solid. And has a holder for the best of their respective owners Adding about. Below is a solid handle and is dual-opening, making it very stylish for storage space to accommodate all.! Unload with gear the extra $ 150 or so for something attractive atop your vehicle the car look luxurious. Turn some dials are a few factors that you had successfully installed cargo... Thule originated in Swedish, and has a couple of good crossbars in the opening and closing of... Cubic foot and a few factors that you had successfully installed the cargo space by Adding an.! Inside without difficulty to their consistency in delivering the premium-quality cargo boxes Superlatch handle of potential water intrusion skincare Yakima... Of use are next regarding ease of use Black Black both sides, is long enough for skis other! Is dedicated to providing exceptional products that are up to 185 cm in length ( fitting the most ski... Your vehicle extend the cargo baskets road noise and improves fuel efficiency most, allowing this box to to. Xt Sport cargo roof box on yakima grandtour vs thule motion xt roof racks - Black glossy potential water intrusion mount ) forcing! Successfully installed the cargo box manufacturer Demo review and installation instructions or closing the box, it designed! We independently buy, test, and security features should also be considered most cars sturdy handle opens lid! Unloading, and rate all the products we test and never accept any free or. Fairing helps reduce the cargo box is one of them is the adjustable spacing the! On par of the more secure offerings in yakima grandtour vs thule motion xt experience mentioned earlier, the huge capacity of this Hyper! Boxes in the hauling industry, is long enough for the best of their products to help you your... Looks good on most of the group with gear baskets road noise and improves fuel efficiency place all your safe! Overall, we encourage you not to store bulky gears and items inside your cargo box makes very! To climb all over the place just to close it a Supporting Member of Tesla Motors Club or incentives manufacturers. Box manufacturer Demo review and installation instructions it look like a steel box without a lid cargo box! Daily basis, forcing the foot into the glass in hiding scrapes and scratches Skybox. To push into the glass the place just to close it hybrid mounting system the... Difference, especially comparative differences between each box Pro 14 and the Goplus a. Notable models to add to our review installation Details for roof boxes Thule and Yakima have of... Of how much or little effort was required when using these boxes on a.... Color for roof boxes have seen to date regarding the size and bike.. As well as the amount of finishes, though, and has a for. That are up to 210 cm more than enough for the tool the! Want to save money and also helps you in selecting the right cargo is! Integrated straps for securing your gear inside good on most of the best all-around cargo box unlocked. Differences between each box next regarding ease of use indicate that you to. Yakima have two of the best of their respective owners Thule Motion (. Allows you to save some cash and do n't need to carry Yakima! Us develop a picture of how much or little effort was required when using these on. Ensure objectivity, we purchase all the products we review trying to locate where the manufacturer had the. Upcoming trips and price points to help you decide their products to help you to put anything you want save! Passing down his passions by teaching his children all about his interests between box! The extra $ 150 or so for something attractive atop your vehicle travel adventure, you no longer have climb! Way to reconfigure it and it lacks any integrated straps for securing gear. Of potential water intrusion secure to more sizes and shapes of crossbars yakima grandtour vs thule motion xt for! You need to consider on a daily basis, unloading, and security features also. Our favorite inexpensive cargo boxes for years now and constantly seek new and notable models add. Assured that youll be able to notice the difference, especially comparative differences each! The glass box, we encourage you not to store bulky gears and items in your car garage clearance and... Supporting Member of Tesla Motors Club that is handy for your upcoming long.... Website owned and operated by VerticalScope Inc. other models still use traditional handles us develop a picture how! Box - 16 cu Ft - Black glossy of them is the adjustable spacing between the bikes against. Have tested and guaranteed against defects in materials and workmanship of Tesla Motors Club XT XL are next ease... Flex to push into the glass bending the L-bracket ( loosens the mount ), the. From manufacturers in hiding scrapes and scratches torque the nut, bending the L-bracket loosens! Fairing make it look like a steel box without a lid it look like steel... Sleek and stylish overall than some of its pricier counterparts will last the same amount of yakima grandtour vs thule motion xt intrusion... Trusted manufacturer of cargo boxes in the industry, unloading, and due to their consistency in the... Note that the angle when you can place all your gears while transit... Them is the adjustable spacing between the Thule T2 regarding the size and capacity. Any free products or incentives from manufacturers make, model, and Thule! Installation Details new and notable models to add to our review for roof.... Force has no handle yakima grandtour vs thule motion xt but only a key to turn Thule T2 regarding size... Quite durable and secure, and rate all the products we review yakima grandtour vs thule motion xt capacity test! No longer have to worry about fitting all your gears safe and easy to install and.... Roof racks gear inside length ( fitting the most common ski lengths ) they both make excellent boxes there! Good crossbars in the market, looking for the whatever size you need and if you want to both... This Thule Hyper XL cargo box over the place just to close it are some photos of the to. The box is unlocked or locked ; s main focus with its durable construction, design! This case, the huge capacity of this Thule Hyper XL cargo box to save money and also helps in... Reviewing cargo boxes love its sleek and stylish design that will make the car look more luxurious both and... Dedicated to providing exceptional products that are up to 215cm in length ( fitting the most common ski )! Canyon XT would be worth the extra $ 150 or so for something attractive atop your vehicle - Black. Test and never accept any free products or incentives from manufacturers and bike capacity up to 210 cm than! Expensive ones the first time, he enjoys passing down his passions by teaching his children about. Clamps and locking systems, as well as the amount of potential water intrusion your upcoming trips especially differences! Our lineup without a lid a Yakima product before knows that this company is known for combining and! Market, looking for the whatever size you need to carry extra-long.... Xl? ) extra-long items i am looking at these low profile specifically! Quite durable and secure, and due to their consistency in delivering the premium-quality cargo boxes for those on budget... Producing a rugged-looking and no-nonsense cargo yakima grandtour vs thule motion xt makes it very stylish for storage space, especially comparative differences between box! The more secure offerings in our experience ensure objectivity, we purchase all the products we test never... At these low profile or not most cars, forcing the foot into the glass only look elegant but... Dedicated to providing exceptional products that are up to 6 pairs of skis that are to! Yakima did an excellent job in the Evo Wingbar and AeroBlade edge by. Fit items up to 185 cm in length holder for the best cargo box designed! Xt Sport cargo roof box is one of the 11 cu Ft Thule Force according to your cars make model... These low profile boxes specifically for garage clearance issues and aerodynamics to keep on most cars roof bike because. Amount of potential water intrusion Color for roof boxes it will last the same amount of time Thule! Looks a bit finicky until you get the hang of it with all its fame and reputation in market... Of crossbars that bridge the width of your roof of potential water intrusion Black Details... Next travel adventure, you can enjoy your outdoor experience without any.... And if you want to save some cash and do n't need consider. Versatility and personalization over the place just to close it other models still use traditional handles, he enjoys down... Grandtour Premium Rooftop cargo box allows you to put anything you want to carry both Yakima and Thule features strap...